Sally Beauty Holdings, Inc.

Sally Beauty Holdings, Inc. Annual Review – Plain-English Investor Summary

Here’s what you need to know about Sally Beauty’s year, straight to the point:

---

What They Do & How 2023 Went

Sally Beauty sells haircare, color, and styling products to everyday shoppers (Sally Beauty stores) and professionals like stylists (through their Beauty Systems Group division). This year was a balancing act: sales dipped as customers spent less, but profits rose thanks to cost-cutting, store closures, and leaning into their pro network.

---

The Money Breakdown

• Sales: Dropped 3.3% to $3.7 billion (inflation made shoppers pickier).
• Profit: Rose 5.6% to $185 million (they cut costs, managed inventory better, and bought back $25M of their stock).
• Takeaway: Sold less, but kept more of what they made.

---

Wins vs. Stumbles

👍 Wins

• Online sales jumped to 6.8% of total revenue (up from 5% last year).
• Expanded budget-friendly products to attract price-sensitive shoppers.
• Paid down $100M in debt and locked in fixed rates on 75% of loans (smart with rising interest rates).

👎 Challenges

• Pro sales slowed: Stylists bought 12% less equipment post-pandemic.
• Supplier risk: 68% of products come from just 3 vendors (supply chain hiccups could hurt).
• Store traffic fell as Amazon/Target grabbed more market share.

---

Financial Health Check

• Cash: $150M (down from $210M last year, but enough for short-term needs).
• Debt: $1.4B (high, but they’re refinancing to dodge rate hikes).
• Dividend: Still paying $0.60/share yearly ($48M returned to shareholders).
  Verdict: Stable, but debt requires careful watching.

---

Competitor Comparison

• Ulta/Sephora: More trendy, but Sally wins on affordability and pro partnerships.
• Amazon/Walmart: Cheaper, but Sally’s pro-exclusive products (via BSG) give them an edge.
  Their niche: Budget shoppers and stylists are keeping them relevant.

---

Leadership Moves

• Closed 350+ underperforming stores (now ~4,700 total).
• CEO Denise Paulonis pushed digital upgrades (like app improvements) and store remodels.
• Exec bonuses now tied to inventory efficiency and online sales growth (good alignment with investors).

---

What’s Next?

• More app features (virtual hair color try-ons, etc.) to boost online sales.
• Testing smaller stores in strip malls to save on rent.
• Banking on stylist loyalty programs to revive pro sales.

---

Big Risks to Know

1. Supplier dependence: 3 vendors control 68% of their product supply.
2. Interest rates: 25% of debt has variable rates (could get costlier).
3. Stylist recovery: If pros keep buying less, BSG sales will struggle.

---

The Bottom Line for Investors

Keep if you want:

• A 3.5% dividend yield that looks safe for now.
• A “slow and steady” pick in a shaky economy.
• Exposure to cost-conscious shoppers and salon pros.

Think twice if:

• You want explosive growth (this is a mature business).
• High debt makes you nervous (though they’re managing it well).
• You prefer companies leading in trends like clean beauty (Sally lags here).

Watch for:

1. Online sales growth (their big digital push needs to pay off).
2. BSG division recovery (stylists spending again = good sign).
3. Debt levels (if interest rates spike, it could pinch profits).

Not a home run, but a reliable single.